Week in (brief) review - FAILCLASS edition
Nov. 7th, 2009 04:26 pmI'm really tired this week. Still.
I'll try to keep this short.
In fact, I'm so lazy I'll post photos of the teacher's outline/summary pages, then elaborate on the notes on them.
Week 10
Day 17.5
On Friday I happened to encounter he-of-the-40-minute-presentation (Kris) at the bus stop. He was with two of his friends, who were fortunate to be in the other section of the course, taught by some other instructor, who is, apparently, really entertaining. Kris laments ("She is totally a communist!") our teacher's fumbling grasp of English. On recalling his super-long presentation, he says that despite being asked to wrap it up at the 35-minute mark, he endeavored to talk until he was finished his presentation because, well, if you asked the class whom they'd prefer to listen to, him or the teacher, the answer would be obvious.
Day 18

* "Com-meh-TIT-ters" ("competitors")
Day 18.5 (Wednesday)
I bought a red pen.
She sends out an email saying that she wants to talk about the final essay for the class (due in 2 weeks).
Day 19

She says that she'll be around all day today, so if we have any questions about choosing a topic to please talk to her. (I'm not even sure how many of us have ideas for topics yet.) Quick, kinda boring student presentation on girls studying math and science and giving grade incentives to students who take advanced math and science classes (seriously, wtf?)
Teacher shows some video about representations of masculinity and femininity in the media. We don't finish. We're supposed to discuss it next class. Um... this isn't SOC 301 (Sociology of Gender). I took that last year, and we actually had interesting discussions on it.
After class, she sends out an email stressing that if we have any questions, we should arrange to talk to her because it's better to have everything straightened out before having to turn in the papers. (Duh?) Except with worse English. (If you're one of those people who knows about "EPIC FAIL", this email was almost as bad as that.)
Loose ends:
From two weeks ago:
I also almost forgot to note one more thing: The campus technology peoples finished hooking up the ceiling-mounted projector in the classroom, so all a teacher needs is to ask the campus technology peoples for an access code and a key to the keyboard/mouse drawer and then they'd be able to use that projector, as well as the computer console in the classroom. And there was a note on the door on Tuesday indicating as such. Yet we persist in having the educational resource technology peoples wheel in the mobile projector every class. What, does someone not have one of those computer video cables or something (the mobile projector trolleys come with one)? Or, hey, maybe you can put your files on a flash drive and plug it into the classroom computer? ;-)
Homework for you, the reader:
Compare and contrast reflection and research essays. Be sure to address the areas of content, structure, style, and tone.
Now for some non-fail:
I spent a day or two assembling this fan-made redesign of the game Battle Line. The redesign is by Sampo Sikiö, which goes to show that the Nerdiverse (um... I mean the Helsinki University of Technology) is capable of producing creative people:

I'll try to keep this short.
In fact, I'm so lazy I'll post photos of the teacher's outline/summary pages, then elaborate on the notes on them.
Week 10
Day 17.5
On Friday I happened to encounter he-of-the-40-minute-presentation (Kris) at the bus stop. He was with two of his friends, who were fortunate to be in the other section of the course, taught by some other instructor, who is, apparently, really entertaining. Kris laments ("She is totally a communist!") our teacher's fumbling grasp of English. On recalling his super-long presentation, he says that despite being asked to wrap it up at the 35-minute mark, he endeavored to talk until he was finished his presentation because, well, if you asked the class whom they'd prefer to listen to, him or the teacher, the answer would be obvious.
Day 18

- Why are we still on the topic of racism? This must be her Ph.D. thesis topic or something.
- "Critical discourse analysis" = whining about "loaded" words ("discourse" can also include imagery, not just text - she didn't mention this?). She uses example of pejorative words used to describe Chinese immigrants in the early 20th century.
- Edward Said (of Orientalism fame) has a surname which should be pronounced "Saïd". Two syllables. >_>
- Textbook chapter referred to in the summary sheet is the one that was read for ... oh gosh ... Week 6. She also refers to one of the other readings from that week.
- Her Ph.D supervisor shows up to talk a little about the reading for today, which was out of her book. It's about racism. Whoopee. I bet the student presenter felt a lot of pressure, hoping that he wasn't misrepresenting the author's words. But it was nice to hear the professor -- an actual, published, expert -- talk on the subject.
* "Com-meh-TIT-ters" ("competitors")
Day 18.5 (Wednesday)
I bought a red pen.
She sends out an email saying that she wants to talk about the final essay for the class (due in 2 weeks).
Day 19

- She arrives 13 minutes late. Two more minutes and, by convention, we'd be allowed to go home.
- I marked a couple of typographic errors on the handout with my red pen. I didn't feel like marking style/grammar notes.
- Says that students had asked if she had any clearer expectations/outline for the final essay, and she had said that she didn't want to give that kind of outline. But now she's marked most of the reflection papers, and feels that maybe she should give us an outline. There it is on that sheet.
- She wants print and electronic copies of the final essay because she wants to check our references.
- She rants on about how too many people, in their reflection essays, merely wrote about how their experiences corresponded/did-not-correspond to the stuff we'd read. She wanted a critical analysis of our experiences. I'm still trying to figure out what that means (the following is my understanding of the matter):
- Pick a school experience
- Whinge about how it contributed to and/or replicates social inequalities
- Relate that to a class reading
Isn't that still just comparing an experience to a reading? - She also rants about how she wanted a clear introduction, thesis, and conclusion in our reflective essays. I don't know about you, but here are other reflection papers (the last one not strictly a reflection paper) that I've written and done well on. Surprise, they don't have specific thesis statements!
- Being Captain Obvious (refer to the photo of the handout) makes for a dull paper.
- We don't get the reflection essays back until next week anyway.
- Reflection essay != Research essay. They're totally different creatures.
- In a research essay, yes, we understand that a thesis statement is expected.
- "In the final paper I expect proper grammar and complete sentences." Uhh... I have no comment on this comment.
- Oh, and also, APA format generally refers to the citation format (strictly speaking, it does include some general style/formatting guidelines, but those are meant more for publications), so I find the use of the parentheses on the handout interesting.
- In a research essay, yes, we understand that a thesis statement is expected.
Loose ends:
From two weeks ago:
This incremental review idea is the most confusing and not very well-conceived thing I've heard of.Hey, yeah, what happened to that, anyway? ;-)
I also almost forgot to note one more thing: The campus technology peoples finished hooking up the ceiling-mounted projector in the classroom, so all a teacher needs is to ask the campus technology peoples for an access code and a key to the keyboard/mouse drawer and then they'd be able to use that projector, as well as the computer console in the classroom. And there was a note on the door on Tuesday indicating as such. Yet we persist in having the educational resource technology peoples wheel in the mobile projector every class. What, does someone not have one of those computer video cables or something (the mobile projector trolleys come with one)? Or, hey, maybe you can put your files on a flash drive and plug it into the classroom computer? ;-)
Homework for you, the reader:
Compare and contrast reflection and research essays. Be sure to address the areas of content, structure, style, and tone.
Now for some non-fail:
I spent a day or two assembling this fan-made redesign of the game Battle Line. The redesign is by Sampo Sikiö, which goes to show that the Nerdiverse (um... I mean the Helsinki University of Technology) is capable of producing creative people:



